Roger Federer and Alexander Zverev’s comments about Jannik Sinner and Carlos Alcaraz have been proven very wrong

0
22

Roger Federer and Alexander Zverev have both argued that tournament organisers have slowed down tennis courts to favour Carlos Alcaraz and Jannik Sinner.

“I understand the safety net that the tournament directors see, making the surface slower; for the weaker player, he has to hit extra amazing shots to beat [Jannik] Sinner, whereas if it’s quick, he can only maybe blast a few at the right time and he gets past. That’s where the tournament directors think: ‘I’d kind of like to have Sinner and [Carlos] Alcaraz in the finals, you know?’ It works for the game,” said Federer on the ‘Served with Andy Roddick‘ podcast in 2025.

“I think the tournament directors are going towards that direction because, obviously, they want Jannik and Carlos to do well every tournament, and that’s what they prefer,” said Zverev at the 2025 Shanghai Masters.

Federer and Zverev’s comments caused quite a stir last year, but were they fair? New data has suggested whether Alcaraz and Sinner are really receiving preferential treatment.

Court speeds have actually increased since 2018

The Court Pace Index (CPI) measures how fast different tennis courts play. Interestingly enough, the CPI for the six hard-court Masters 1000 tournaments and the ATP Finals is higher now than it was eight years ago.

CPI changes (2018-2026)

Tournament

2018 CPI

2026 CPI

Difference

Indian Wells

27.9

39.3

+11.4

Miami Open

30.4

39.2

+8.8

Canadian Open

28.8

36.5

+7.7

Cincinnati Open

31.6

40.4

+8.8

Shanghai Masters

39.9

43.3

+3.4

Paris Masters

34.6

50.0

+15.4

ATP Finals

40.3

45.8

+5.5

Average

33.4

42.1

+8.7

CPI changes (2018-2026)

That data suggests Federer and Zverev were wrong, and that tournament directors haven’t slowed down courts to favour Sinner and Alcaraz. However, these numbers don’t tell the full story.

While the court speeds may have increased, the ball speeds have certainly decreased. The likes of Taylor Fritz and Novak Djokovic have both criticised the quality of balls used on tour, which slows down the pace of play.

“You know, these balls that we use on the tour, also on the Slams, they get slower, and they were definitely slower on average compared to, say, if I go back 10, 15 years ago,” said Djokovic at Wimbledon earlier this year.

Federer and Zverev may have been wrong to say that the courts are slower, but they were right to suggest that the pace of the game has decreased. However, there is no evidence to suggest that this has been done to favour Alcaraz and Sinner.

Jannik Sinner’s response to Alexander Zverev’s claim

After winning his first match at the 2025 Shanghai Masters, Sinner was asked for his thoughts on Zverev’s claim that the courts had been slowed to favour him and Alcaraz.

“You know, me and Carlos, we don’t make the courts. It’s not our decision. We try to adapt ourselves to every situation. I feel like still every week is a bit different,” he said.

Sinner and Alcaraz have dominated men’s tennis on all surfaces. The Italian and Spaniard have both won ‘big titles’ on indoor and outdoor hard courts, clay courts, and grass courts.

Carlos Alcaraz’s ‘big titles’ by surface

  • Outdoor hard – 6 (2022 US Open, 2025 US Open, 2022 Miami Open, 2023 Indian Wells, 2024 Indian Wells, 2025 Cincinnati Open)

  • Indoor hard – 1 (2026 Paris Masters)

  • Clay – 6 (2024 French Open, 2025 French Open, 2022 Madrid Open, 2023 Madrid Open, 2025 Monte Carlo Masters, 2025 Italian Open)

  • Grass – 2 (2023 Wimbledon, 2024 Wimbledon)

Jannik Sinner’s ‘big titles’ by surface

  • Outdoor hard – 9 (2024 Australian Open, 2024 US Open, 2025 Australian Open, 2023 Canadian Open, 2024 Miami Open, 2024 Cincinnati Open, 2024 Shanghai Masters, 2026 Indian Wells, 2026 Miami Open)

  • Indoor hard – 3 (2024 ATP Finals, 2025 ATP Finals, 2025 Paris Masters)

  • Clay – 3 (2026 Monte Carlo Masters, 2026 Madrid Open, 2026 Italian Open)

  • Grass – 2 (2025 Wimbledon, 2026 Wimbledon)

Zverev has won ‘big titles’ on three of the four surfaces, but unlike Sinner and Alcaraz, has yet to lift the Wimbledon trophy at the All England Club, although he did come close this year, losing to the Italian in the final.

Alexander Zverev’s ‘big titles’ by surface

  • Outdoor hard – 3 (2026 US Open, 2017 Canadian Open, 2021 Cincinnati Open)

  • Indoor hard – 3 (2018 ATP Finals, 2021 ATP Finals, 2024 Paris Masters)

  • Clay – 5 (2026 French Open, 2017 Italian Open, 2018 Madrid Open, 2021 Madrid Open, 2024 Italian Open)

  • Grass – 0

Only time will tell which player will win more titles in 2027, and whether court speeds will play a role. Zverev and Alcaraz can both add another indoor hard-court title to their trophy cabinets this week at the ATP Finals. After winning their opening matches in straight sets, Zverev will return to play Ben Shelton on Tuesday, November 17, before Alcaraz plays Daniil Medvedev on Wednesday, November 18.

O que achou dessa notícia? Deixe um comentário abaixo e/ou compartilhe em suas redes sociais. Assim conseguiremos informar mais pessoas sobre o que acontece no mundo do tênis!

Convidamos você a clicar em Página de Parceiros para conhecer os parceiros do Tênis Portal e acessar seus sites.

Esta notícia foi originalmente publicada em: Fonte original

Tênis Portal tem o patrocínio da Pró-Tênis Barra